Can you get "the things a degree promises" outside of college?

In his new book, "Hacking Your Education," author Dale Stephens says: "We shouldn’t be asking, How can I get a college degree? Instead, we should ask, How can I get the things a degree promises?"

Is it possible for Americans to get all the benefits of a college degree without going to a 4-year college?

 
article-image
Dale J. Stephens espouses the working model of the 'hackademic' as the best way forward
× Your argument has been added successfully!

But we have no permission to:
  • Tweet on your behalf (Twitter)
  • Publish on your Timeline (Facebook)
× Your argument has been added successfully!

But we have no permission to:
  • Tweet on your behalf (Twitter)
  • Publish on your Timeline (Facebook)

Yes


2

In seeking employment, "Experience" is more important than "Knowledge."

 

 0 Replies

Reply in: Support Dispute

× Your comment has been added successfully!

But we have don't have permission to:
  • Tweet on your behalf (Twitter)
  • Publish on your Timeline (Facebook)

0

Knowledge + Network do not require college

 

 0 Replies

Reply in: Support Dispute

× Your comment has been added successfully!

But we have don't have permission to:
  • Tweet on your behalf (Twitter)
  • Publish on your Timeline (Facebook)

No


1

Most large companies still look for that 4-year degree.

 

 2 Replies

Reply in: Support Dispute

× Your comment has been added successfully!

But we have don't have permission to:
  • Tweet on your behalf (Twitter)
  • Publish on your Timeline (Facebook)

Yes


No links on the Yes side have been added yet

No


No links on the No side have been added yet

 

3

Arguments

(2 Replies)


  • Nash Yielding user photo

    2

    Nash Yielding Mar 05, 2013

    In seeking employment, "Experience" is more important than "Knowledge."

    At their best, most colleges and universities may offer students knowledge, but only in the real world can they get experience. A lot of recent grads have trouble getting a job because they don't have any experience, and they don't have experience because they haven't had a job; they're trapped in a vicious cycle. By following a more self-directed ("hackademic") path to your own education, you can seek internships, apprenticeships, and other work experiences while your peers are cramming for tests and procrastinating on Facebook. By the time your peers graduate from college and enter the job market with their Knowledge, you'll be competing with them using your Experience.

     

    Dispute Support

    × Your comment has been added successfully!

    But we have don't have permission to:
    • Tweet on your behalf (Twitter)
    • Publish on your Timeline (Facebook)
    Your comment has been updated successfully

  • Nash Yielding user photo

    1

    Nash Yielding Mar 05, 2013

    Most large companies still look for that 4-year degree.

    Let's face it, your major and GPA are still the first things a lot of HR departments are going to look for on your résumé when deciding whether to throw it in the trash or give it a closer read.



    Advocates for alternative forms of education are going to have a hard time overcoming inertia in this area. What incentive does your average hiring manager have to take a chance on you, without your "piece of paper"? If they hire you and things work out, they don't get a bonus or even an extra pat on the back; but if you turn out to be a dud, they're going to look bad and they know it.

     

     

    Dispute Support

    × Your comment has been added successfully!

    But we have don't have permission to:
    • Tweet on your behalf (Twitter)
    • Publish on your Timeline (Facebook)
    Your comment has been updated successfully

    • Peter White user photo

      1

      Peter White Mar 05, 2013

      The career that you choose is a big factor into how much a degree is worth. Banking, consulting, advertising, among others, are careers where the name of the university you attended is a huge factor in even getting into the door.  Other industries such as trading, tech, design, etc, the school you attended or even if you have a degree are not very relevant.

      Experience definitely trumps a degree, but in many instances a degree is required to even get the foot in the door.

       

      Dispute Support

      × Your comment has been added successfully!

      But we have don't have permission to:
      • Tweet on your behalf (Twitter)
      • Publish on your Timeline (Facebook)
      Your comment has been updated successfully

      • Ana Luisa user photo

        0

        Ana Luisa Mar 06, 2013

        Your degree and where you obtained it is your first filter to getting the job. The importance of your degree does vary by industry.

         

        Dispute Support

        × Your comment has been added successfully!

        But we have don't have permission to:
        • Tweet on your behalf (Twitter)
        • Publish on your Timeline (Facebook)
        Your comment has been updated successfully

  • Martin Curiel user photo

    0

    Martin Curiel Mar 21, 2013

    Knowledge + Network do not require college

    Absolutely. The degree provides two main things: knowledge + network. For example, with a free internet connection from Starbuck's and my cheap iPad2, I can learn everything there is to know about investing, personal finance, etc. by reading investopedia.com  Through hard work and persistence, I can build a good network of accomplished people that can help me build my career.  A college degree could provide these two things more efficiently, but at the end of the day, everything I can learn or obtain in a college campus can be obtained outside of it.

     

    Dispute Support

    × Your comment has been added successfully!

    But we have don't have permission to:
    • Tweet on your behalf (Twitter)
    • Publish on your Timeline (Facebook)
    Your comment has been updated successfully

Discussion Stats

  • Views: 224
  • Arguments: 3
  • Replies: 2

Activity Feed